Top 10 Best Tool Chests: Comparison Table
Best Overall: Durable + Convenient - Goplus Tool Chest 20-inch Portable Tool Box Steel Cabinet Review
American-made, GoPlus's 20-inch portable tool chest is made of heavy-duty steel, and the powder-coat paint increases the item's durability even further. This toolbox on wheels is extremely easy to maintain, too. Just remember to wipe it with a simple sponge or cloth. It's easy to move around thanks to the ergonomic handle, and the smooth rounded edges will prevent any possible impact. The ball-bearing slides of the drawers open and close smoothly, but only when you want them to. And for extra security, there are two latches for locks that will close all the drawers in one move.
This tool chest is an excellent choice for everyone who is tired of Chinesium and favors honest American quality.
Why We Like It
- Made of rugged steel
- Covered in durable and dirt-resistant paint
- Comfortable smart-design handle
Ergonomic: Thoughtful Design - Husky Extra Deep 46 In. 9-drawer Mobile Workbench Review
This mobile workbench from Husky is actually quite big and heavy-duty. Fortunately, almost no assembly is required, except for attaching the handle and the wheels. Given Husky tool chest size and weight, you might want to use someone's help when you attach the wheels. And, you'll definitely need it if you want to take it upstairs. The 9 lockable drawers are extra-deep: 21.7 inches against the usual 18. It's not a tool chest with speakers, but an extra touch is the integrated power strip that includes 4 regular sockets and 2 USB outlets.
This workbench from Husky is best for storing tools that you don't use too often.
Why We Like It
- Very rugged
- Extra spacious
- Integrated electricity strip and outlets
Long Lifespan Item: Goplus 6-drawer Rolling Tool Chest Review
This rolling tool chest from GoPlus is, in fact, a two-piece set: the upper box is detachable. Both pieces are made of durable cold-rolled steel, and the anti-rust paint increases the durability even more. Customers point out how compact these intermediate tool chests are when they arrive. In part, it's because GoPLus packs its shipments smartly and ergonomically. But still, this tool chest is smaller than it looks on pictures. Aside from the advertised 6 drawers (2 larger and 4 smaller ones), there are 2 trays and additional spacious storage space in the bottom tool chest.
This is an excellent solution for a tinkerer or a handyman, but it probably isn't the best machinist tool chest.
Why We Like It
- Very durable steel
- Glossy corrosion-resistant paint
- Secure keyed locking system
Secure: Craftsman 3-drawer Metal Portable Chest Toolbox Red Review
This Craftsman's 3-drawer portable toolbox has a 2.5-inches deep top tray and 2-inch deep drawers that slide smoothly and seamlessly thanks to the smart-design under the drawer handles. The draw-bolt latches to keep the lids closed and secure. They close automatically when you close the tray, but they also will open themselves the next time you open the upper tray, so you should watch out for that. You can get rid of this feature by removing the lid pin. Overall, this Craftsman tool chest feels sturdy and rugged, built to last.
Customer reviews often insist that this toolbox is more convenient and enjoyable to use as stationary than as portable.
- Draw-bolt latches and hasp-and-staple lock for ultimate security
- Smooth-sliding drawers
- Sturdy feel
- Heavier than it looks
Sturdy: Stanley 037025H 50 Gallon Mobile Chest Review
40-Galon 037025H 50-Gallon chest from Stanley resembles a suitcase, especially when you see the pull-out handle. This Stanley tool chest is, however, not only more durable but also bigger than a regular suitcase. It is 34.25 inches deep and, as advertised, can house up to 50 gallons. The drawback is that it makes it impossible to use to carry luggage since most airlines consider it oversized. Nevertheless, it's perfect for its intended use – storing instruments of any size, as well as for some more creative uses: housing a solar power generator or transporting gear and equipment for horse competitions.
These Stanley mobile tool chests are excellent for transporting larger pieces of equipment.
- The price is quite reasonable for such a massive item
- Heavy-duty wheels
- There are not too many products like this on the market
- Only one tray inside
- The plastic hinges that keep the lid open are weak
Versatile: Apollo Tools 2-drawer Heavy-duty Steel Chest Review
Despite this 2-Drawer chest from Apollo looks more like a tool box, it weighs more like a mid tool chest – 11 pounds when empty. The first thing to address would be its pink color. Why not make a more 'tame' blue tool chest or a green tool chest? There are two reasons for this. First, it's bright and makes the chest and the instruments easier to find. Second, pink is the color of the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, and Apollo donates to them from every purchase. The unusual choice of color also makes it better suited for a variety of alternative uses – storage of school supplies, sewing, knitting, sculpting, cooking, etc.
With this firm and versatile steel chest, Apollo proves that pink color can belong in your workshop, and it's one of the best tool chest 2020 selection can offer.
- Choosing this product, you help fight breast cancer
- Sturdier than it looks
- The bright color helps you locate it in a room effortlessly
- Too heavy for its size
- Only allows for one small lock for security
Roomy: Milwaukee Heavy-duty, Drawer 16 Tool Chest 46 In. And Rolling Cabinet Set Review
Like all Milwaukee products, their heavy-duty rolling tool chest can boast rugged charm and unmatched durability. The all-melded steel construction allows this pro steel tool chest to hold up to 1800 pounds of weight, and the textured powder coating will last for ages. This Milwaukee tool chest is 62.5 inches tall and has 27223 cubic inches of storage capacity with 16 drawers of different sizes. Moving it around, however, is effortless thanks to the polypropylene fixed-and-swivel casters and three tubular handles. You must be ready, though, that all these advantages reflect in the item's price.
Like everything from Milwaukee, this chest is for someone who appreciates the quality and durability of what they keep in their garage.
- Milwaukee's unmatched quality and durability
- Despite the heavy gauge, it's easy to move around
- Extremely spacious
- Quite expensive
- The lock is somewhat finicky
Cost-effective: WEN 73015 Garage Glider Rolling Tool Chest Seat Review
WEN clearly prioritized maneuverability when designing their 73015 rolling tool chest seat. The 4 ball-bearing swivel casters allow you to glide seamlessly in any direction around your garage. These middle tool chests even have 'wings' which are actually two foldable magnetic trays for nuts and bolts – both neat-looking and practical. As for the seat, it's finished with durable vinyl and quite soft, may seem too soft for some. Also, customers state that the tool rack isn't good for all instruments and sometimes requires additional adjustment.
WEN's the gliding tool chest is an excellent cost-effective solution for those who need to move around their garage quickly or have hindered mobility.
- Efficient maneuvering
- Additional magnetic trays for screws and bolts
- Excellent customer service
- There is no lock and no opportunity to install it
- The wheels turn out somewhat fragile when used extensively
Accessories Included: Keter 240762 5 Drawer Modular Garage & Tool Organizer Review
Keter is one of those companies whose products many of us dismiss as 'plastic junk' without even giving it a chance. However, we must remember that plastic doesn't rust as metal does, and its quality and durability has improved significantly over the years. Keter's 240762 5-drawer tool organizer's lightness makes it great for any use – from craft storage to gardening or even scrapbooking. It's quite compact, and you can easily fit it in your apartment or even your van. And the central locking system is as secure as you'd expect.
This tool organizer from Keter is here to bust the myth that all plastic stuff is worthless.
- 16 removable top chest tool boxes, bins, and dividers to organize your storage space
- Secure locking system
- No lock included
- If a tool gets stuck inside, the drawers get stuck, and you need to disassemble the whole unit
Well-organized Interior: Keter 241008 Masterloader Plastic Portable Rolling Organizer Review
Keter's 241008 portable rolling organizers or simply Masterloader is a unique product. Other large-sized mobile chests are few, made from steel, and belong to a completely different price category. Using an alternative material allows manufacturers to cut down the price, and the polypropylene resin is just as sturdy, but, unlike metal, it's 100% waterproof and resistant to chemical damage. The item looks somewhat futuristic with its automatic central locking system and sliding topmost bins. There are more bins and dividers to let you organize the storage space inside. Unfortunately, it doesn't come in different colors, so you can only have a black tool chest from Keter.
In many situations, you cannot afford to be prejudiced against a non-metal tool chest – for example, if you're a plumber or you need your chest waterproof and resistant to chemical damage. That's when Keter's Masterloader will be your loyal friend – and it's not heavy on the budget, too!
- A unique product – the nearest analogs are made of metal and are much more expensive
- Polypropylene resin is arguably more durable than metal
- Automatic locking for increased security
- Heavier than you'd expect a non-metal chest to be
- The bottom area has less room than you'd imagine – because of the wheels
Even though the choice of any chest cabinet remains a very individual process, first-time buyers should always consider the following aspects. The right combination of those ensures ultimate performance for every separate homeowner.
How To Choose The Best Tool Chest
First, consider the preferred storage capacity of your ideal toolbox chest. Think which tools you’re going to store in there, their number, dimensions, etc. Decide if you need a tool chest organizer or a simple box with few sorting capabilities. Consider where you are going to use these instruments, and if you need any mobility from a tool box. A lot of shoppers focus on brands and their reputation in the market, but we believe you have to consider size and functionality first. Often, brand names have even less value than colors. Few reasonable people would go with a lousy red tool chest only because it’s their favorite brand or shade.
If it’s going to be a tool chest with tools, you obviously need to consider the number of items you need to store in there. Also, think if you’re planning any new purchases in the future. It’s always a good idea to have some extra space, but don’t go overboard. Sometimes, size matters. Besides, a large tool chest will not fit into a small garage.
Frame Durability Material Quality
This feature is especially important if you need to store plenty of professional equipment, which is quite heavy. Obviously, a plastic tool chest will never be as durable as a wooden one. Still, quality plastic is often sturdier than some metal. So, when shopping for stainless tool chests, double-check if the frame is single or dual. Sure, the second one is a more durable option.
Inner Layout and Organization
Shelves, drawers, and their placement are sometimes even more important than overall storage capacity. If internal storage units are too small or too large, you won’t have a chance to sort out all the instruments properly. So, plenty of valuable space will be lost. Sometimes, a carefully designed, a small tool chest is more efficient than a large item with just a few shelves or drawers.
Best Tool Chest Types
Each of the following tool chest examples can be a great fit if these storage items match your individual needs. As for the common production materials and popular designs, each type has its pluses and minuses. At the same time, they all deserve some attention.
Tool Chest Combo
Tool chest combo is a perfect choice for expert DIYers and professionals. This is a large item with multiple drawers. Besides, all of these drawers have different dimensions, so you will easily sort out smaller instruments from bulkier ones. While such combos are not exactly compact, they offer supreme storage capacity. Many of them come with wheels and allow some portability around your workshop.
Portable Tool Box
This one is a more compact solution and not that different from most tool box organizers. Normally made of plastic or stainless steel, these boxes are perfect for transporting certain tools you need outside the house. Choosing the best portable toolbox is especially important for professional contractors who carry their pro instrument to work. It’s also a good idea for people who hire professional contractors and have only the most basic instruments at home.
Tool Box On Wheels
A tool chest on wheels provides extra mobility, so you can move it around your garage or workshop. However, it’s not exactly a portable solution because most of these items are quite heavy (even without any equipment) and bulky. It is a mobile tool chest in theory, but its mobility is usually limited to your house, yard, or garage.
Wood Tool Chest
A solid wood tool chest is a classic storage solution that will serve homeowners for decades. Besides, it looks classy and professional. This isn’t a portable toolbox, though — wooden models come without wheels, so you will have to fetch your instruments manually, even when working in the garage. On the other hand, if interior decor matters, wood may be the only choice.
Stainless Steel Tool Chest
A stainless steel tool chest is a very popular choice for many DIYers. Its durable frame, rust-resistant qualities, and relatively small weight make this material type a good addition to many households. Besides, they come in a variety of sizes, shapes, and colors. You can even get a pink tool chest if colors matter.
Metal Tool Chest
The metal tool chest is another common and generally affordable solution. However, you should go with high-quality material if you want your chest tool box to last. The thinner the metal is, the less durable it’s going to be. We suggest double-checking the frame and going with dual frame models.
Lockable Storage Chest
A lockable storage chest is a good option for parents who want to child-proof their workshops and contractors who carry instruments to work. Still, most DIYers can do without such models. While lockable models come in different designs and configurations, most of them are still compact boxes with few storage compartments.
Plastic Tool Chest
Quality plastic can be a top tool chest example if designed and manufactured properly. It’s affordable, lightweight, and can be quite durable. Of course, plastic will never beat genuine wood or quality stainless steel. But, in comparison to poor quality metal, plastic is a wiser idea for garage tool storage.
Our Recommendation for 2020
Each homeowner’s toolkit is quite individual, even though most of them will have the essential basics. So, the choice of quality tool chest drawer organizer remains quite an individual process. We at Homemakerguide have thoroughly reviewed ten best selling models but still believe that GoPlus’s 20-inch portable tool chest is a perfect choice for most households. Even though plastic products have come a long way and one shouldn’t dismiss them as blindly as we used to, there is still nothing better than a good old American-made steel chest. Its durable construction, impressive storage capacity, and reasonable cost make GoPlus’s 20-inch portable tool chest one of the best tool chest 2020 selection has to offer.
- 1 Top 10 Best Tool Chests: Comparison Table
- 1.1 Best Overall: Durable + Convenient - Goplus Tool Chest 20-inch Portable Tool Box Steel Cabinet Review
- 1.2 Ergonomic: Thoughtful Design - Husky Extra Deep 46 In. 9-drawer Mobile Workbench Review
- 1.3 Long Lifespan Item: Goplus 6-drawer Rolling Tool Chest Review
- 1.4 Secure: Craftsman 3-drawer Metal Portable Chest Toolbox Red Review
- 1.5 Sturdy: Stanley 037025H 50 Gallon Mobile Chest Review
- 1.6 Versatile: Apollo Tools 2-drawer Heavy-duty Steel Chest Review
- 1.7 Roomy: Milwaukee Heavy-duty, Drawer 16 Tool Chest 46 In. And Rolling Cabinet Set Review
- 1.8 Cost-effective: WEN 73015 Garage Glider Rolling Tool Chest Seat Review
- 1.9 Accessories Included: Keter 240762 5 Drawer Modular Garage & Tool Organizer Review
- 1.10 Well-organized Interior: Keter 241008 Masterloader Plastic Portable Rolling Organizer Review
- 2 Buyer's Guide
- 2.1 How To Choose The Best Tool Chest
- 2.2 Best Tool Chest Types
- 3 Our Recommendation for 2020